Skip to content

Supreme Court To Decide Whether Presidents Can Repeal Laws By Disliking Them

Supreme Court To Decide Whether Presidents Can Repeal Laws By Disliking Them

The Supreme Court agreed Friday to hear President Donald Trump’s challenge to federal asylum law, bravely confronting the constitutional crisis that arises whenever Congress enacts a statute and the president feels the statute lacks sufficient respect for his personal preferences. The dispute concerns Trump’s proclamation declaring an “invasion” at the southern border and suspending asylum access for migrants who cross between ports of entry. Federal law allows people physically present in the United States to request asylum, an obsolete procedural detail the administration says should not interfere with the more efficient system of deciding every case before reviewing any of them.

Administration lawyers contend that accepting applications, examining evidence and holding hearings would squander government resources on determining facts after Trump has already determined the outcome. The theory could streamline the executive branch by eliminating judges, records, testimony, statutes and other legacy features that separate presidential irritation from national policy. “We have the greatest asylum system because nobody can use it, and that makes it incredibly fast, probably the fastest anywhere in the world,” Trump said. “You apply, we say no before you apply, and frankly that is due process at a level nobody thought was possible.”

Lower courts nevertheless concluded that a president cannot replace procedures enacted by Congress with a proclamation announcing that circumstances are very serious. The administration appealed, arguing that presidential discretion necessarily includes the discretion to convert a legal right into a museum exhibit: still visible in the U.S. Code, but no longer available for public use. Under the government’s position, the word “invasion” functions as a constitutional solvent, dissolving any statute that obstructs the White House while leaving executive authority with a bright, streak-free finish.

Chief Justice John Roberts and his colleagues are expected to hear arguments in the spring and issue a ruling by late June. The justices must decide whether laws remain binding after a president objects to them, or whether congressional enactments are merely suggestions awaiting executive spell-check. Until then, the administration will continue defending its central constitutional principle: Congress writes the laws, courts interpret them, and the president repeals them by frowning.

* None of the quotes in this article were spoken by an actual person. More info.

Please wait...