Skip to content

Judge Orders Public Park To Remain Public

Judge Orders Public Park To Remain Public

A federal judge ordered the Trump administration to continue permitting ordinary Americans inside East Potomac Park, temporarily blocking President Donald Trump’s plan to close the historic public golf complex and rebuild it into a championship course prestigious enough to keep its current patrons at a respectful distance. U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes’s November 14 order preserves access for two weeks while litigation by preservationists and local golfers proceeds. Legal experts warned that the ruling could establish a radical precedent under which property described as “public” remains available to the public, regardless of whether the president believes it would look better surrounded by paying guests and discreet shrubbery.

Trump sought a 15-month closure to replace East Potomac Golf Links’ suspiciously affordable collection of 18-hole, nine-hole and miniature courses with a tournament-caliber venue capable of making beginners, families and government employees feel properly underdressed. “This judge is forcing innocent Americans to play affordable golf beside regular people, bicycles, fishermen and trees that have never contributed anything to the economy,” Trump said. “It is unconstitutional, very unfair to championship golf, and probably the worst attack on recreation in the history of our country.” The White House said the existing facility’s habit of accommodating multiple skill levels reflected the failed doctrine that recreation should be enjoyable rather than aspirational.

The administration argued that the entire park must close because of a deteriorating seawall and the absence of a golf-course operator, an operational vacuum the government created by terminating the operator’s lease. Reyes called those explanations pretextual, invoking the controversial judicial theory that official explanations should correspond with observable events. Her ruling still permits necessary repairs, continued planning, environmental review and historic-preservation procedures, options White House officials condemned as an extremist demand that the president govern legally, patiently and with paperwork. Trump vowed an expedited appeal, warning that every day East Potomac remains accessible is another day the United States risks being mistaken for a country with municipal recreation. The ruling therefore leaves executive power in its most degraded condition: temporarily unable to convert a public park into a velvet rope.

* None of the quotes in this article were spoken by an actual person. More info.

Please wait...