Skip to content

Senate Republicans Rescue Congress From Constitutional Authority

Senate Republicans Rescue Congress From Constitutional Authority

Senate Republicans protected Congress from the reckless exercise of congressional authority Thursday, rejecting a proposal that would have required lawmakers to approve sweeping tariffs before Americans paid for them. The measure threatened to involve the legislative branch in legislation by restoring its constitutional power over taxes and commerce, responsibilities senators said could interfere with fundraising, television appearances and the careful scheduling of hearings after every decision has already taken effect. Party leaders warned that voting on trade policy would also create a dangerous record showing what each senator believes.

Sens. Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski and Rand Paul supported the proposal, briefly exposing the chamber to Article I before leadership contained the outbreak. Sen. John Fetterman sided with Republicans, endorsing the modern separation of powers under which the president imposes tariffs, businesses raise prices and Congress demands to know who could have allowed such a thing. “Congress has enormous power, beautiful power, but using it creates fingerprints, and fingerprints are terrible when prices go up,” President Donald Trump said. “I make the tariffs. If they work, I did it. If they don’t, Congress should investigate itself and apologize to me.”

Republican leaders noted that the proposal was largely symbolic, making it far too consequential for Senate approval. Washington reserves symbolism for flag pins, empty lecterns, ceremonial votes and declarations that lawmakers are “deeply concerned” by economic policies they have declined to influence. Senators said surrendering tariff authority would preserve their flexibility to praise lower prices, denounce higher prices and blame either result on whichever branch appeared most recently on cable news. The vote followed public frustration over rising household costs, a message lawmakers interpreted as a demand for fewer elected officials to participate in government.

By defeating the measure, senators retained the freedom to condemn every outcome without accepting the reputational hazards of governing. Congress has therefore fulfilled its constitutional duty to regulate commerce by ensuring it will not regulate commerce.

* None of the quotes in this article were spoken by an actual person. More info.

Please wait...