Alito Delays Retirement To Shield Supreme Court From Voters

Justice Samuel Alito has agreed to postpone retirement, sparing the nation from the destabilizing possibility that voters might influence who confirms his successor. Alito said he remains capable of making “a valuable contribution” and would reconsider his future periodically, after reviewing his health, workload and the partisan composition of every institution theoretically unrelated to his work. He also ruled out leaving during a lame-duck Senate session if Democrats gain control, reaffirming the constitutional principle that lifetime appointments must be timed with the precision of a partisan missile launch.

Legal scholars hailed the deliberations as a triumph of judicial independence, now defined as checking which party controls the White House and Senate before independently ordering cardboard boxes. Republicans warned that a poorly scheduled vacancy could permit Democrats to participate in the confirmation process, an institutional calamity the Founders neglected to prevent when they explicitly gave the Senate that power. President Donald Trump praised Alito’s refusal to politicize the Court by retiring under politically inconvenient conditions. “Justice Alito is totally nonpolitical, probably the most nonpolitical justice in history, and that is why he must leave only when I can replace him with another great nonpolitical conservative,” Trump said.

Alito’s continued service protects the Court’s conservative majority from dangerous outside pressures including elections, Senate majorities, demographic change and clocks. Court observers said he may revisit retirement next year after consulting his family, reviewing pending cases and watching cable-news analysts color the Senate map various shades of Republican reassurance. Until then, Americans may take comfort that the Supreme Court remains safely insulated from representative government, particularly when representative government produces the wrong representatives.

* None of the quotes in this article were spoken by an actual person. More info.