Supreme Court Curbs Missouri’s Right To Choose Its Voters
The Supreme Court struck a severe blow Friday against America’s oldest democratic safeguard: permitting elected officials to choose their voters before voters make the mistake of choosing elected officials. For the third time, the justices blocked Missouri from using a Trump-backed congressional map intended to give Republicans an advantage in seven of the state’s eight House districts. The order restores the 2022 boundaries for November’s midterms, forcing candidates to confront the obsolete hazards of competitive elections while absentee voting is already underway.
The rejected 2025 map would have dismantled Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver’s Kansas City-based district, denying Republicans the constitutional liberty to move inconvenient citizens across district lines until their ballots acquire the proper attitude. President Donald Trump condemned the ruling as an attack on representative government. “Missouri drew a beautiful map, maybe the most beautiful map anybody has ever drawn, and now judges want voters deciding elections,” Trump said. “That is election interference, because once you let people choose their representatives, nobody knows what terrible thing they might choose.” The court offered no practical guidance for lawmakers suddenly expected to win seats through persuasion, policy or candidates whom the public can tolerate.
Missouri Gov. Mike Kehoe signed the new boundaries after Trump encouraged Republican-led states to redraw congressional districts before the midterms, a routine act of electoral maintenance comparable to changing the locks shortly before the tenants return. The court’s order suggests maps may require something beyond presidential enthusiasm and a legislature’s sincere preference never to lose. Legal experts warned that the old boundaries could expose Missouri to uncontrolled outbreaks of campaigning, including representatives speaking with undecided voters, parties nominating broadly popular candidates and citizens discovering that their ballots are not merely patriotic confetti.
The ruling also preserves Cleaver’s district long enough for Missourians to vote on the new map themselves, recklessly placing redistricting policy in the hands of people whose principal qualification is living in Missouri. State officials are expected to proceed under the temporary fiction that congressional districts belong to the public rather than the politicians who draw them. In the American constitutional order, democracy works best when voters are kept safely away from choosing the outcome.
* None of the quotes in this article were spoken by an actual person. More info.