ICE Body Cameras Will Record Only Agency’s Best Moments
ICE announced America’s most carefully supervised experiment in government transparency, requiring officers to record their work while reserving the right to prevent the resulting evidence from wandering into public view. Acting ICE Director David J. Venturella said field officers are expected to receive body-worn cameras by the end of August, allowing the agency to document nearly every encounter and disclose whichever portions confirm that nothing objectionable has ever occurred.
Under the policy, footage involving a serious injury or death may be released within 72 hours if officials determine that publication serves ICE’s “best interests.” Recordings may also be withheld under “specific and compelling circumstances,” including the specific circumstance that a recording is especially compelling. The policy resolves the central defect of body cameras: their reckless habit of preserving events before government communications specialists can establish what happened.
President Donald Trump praised the program as a historic advance in selective openness. “We’re going to show everything, absolutely everything, as long as it looks very good for us,” Trump said. “If it looks bad, the camera was probably dishonest, and frankly cameras have been very unfair to this administration.” Officials said taxpayers will receive substantial value from the equipment, which will safeguard evidence on secure government servers beyond the reach of journalists, lawyers, relatives and other context enthusiasts. The agency spent $30.9 million on body-camera equipment in July, assembling what is expected to become the federal government’s largest private archive of publicly funded footage.
Critics said accountability requires independent access to recordings, overlooking ICE’s longstanding independence from critics, oversight, embarrassment and, when necessary, its own cameras. Agency officials emphasized that every released video will undergo a rigorous review to ensure the public sees events from the appropriate angle, at the appropriate speed and with any distracting events immediately before or after the incident removed. Under the new policy, Americans can be certain that whenever ICE releases body-camera footage, the footage will conclusively prove that ICE looks terrific.
* None of the quotes in this article were spoken by an actual person. More info.